How Trump’s Second Term Could Impact the Insurance Industry: Key Takeaways for 2025 and Beyond

Air quality

The re-election of Donald Trump as President marks a shift that may bring notable changes across various sectors, especially for the insurance industry. With a pro-business stance, Trump’s anticipated policies could affect inflation control, globalization, regulatory relief, and innovation within the industry. Here, we explore the potential impacts based on insights from industry experts.

1. Economic Policies and Inflation Control: Boost for Business Insurance?

One of the most anticipated outcomes of Trump’s policies is a focus on reducing inflation. For insurers, lower inflation could mean decreased operational costs, ultimately benefiting customers as well. Bradley Flowers, founder of Portal Insurance, notes that if Trump pursues similar economic policies to his first term, the insurance industry might see reduced claims-related expenses and operational costs.

The insurance sector also stands to gain if Trump implements additional tax cuts, fostering an environment conducive to entrepreneurship. With lower taxes, business owners are likely to expand operations, potentially increasing the demand for business insurance. Additionally, tax relief and business-friendly regulations might encourage more startups and expansions, driving further growth in this segment.

2. Globalization and Protectionism: Navigating Risks and Rewards

While economic growth is promising, Trump’s “America First” agenda could complicate matters for the insurance industry’s global operations. A globalized insurance market allows insurers to spread risk across various regions and industries, fostering stability. However, as Richard Look, president of Vertibrands, highlights, a shift toward domestic production might increase operational costs.

For instance, if Trump encourages U.S.-based manufacturing, the cost of materials could rise as local suppliers may charge more than international counterparts. This could lead to higher insurance rates, particularly for policies covering businesses that rely heavily on imported materials. Although supply chain issues have somewhat stabilized post-pandemic, there remains a concern that policies supporting domestic production could increase costs across various insurance products.

3. Regulatory Relief: A Win for Independent Agencies

Trump’s approach to regulatory policies may benefit independent insurance agencies. A less stringent regulatory environment could ease the operational burdens these agencies face. According to Nathan Riedel, senior vice president of federal government affairs at Big I, the President’s pro-business stance might result in the continuation of favorable tax provisions from the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, such as the 20% small business deduction for pass-through entities.

This type of regulatory relief can help smaller, independent agencies operate more efficiently, making it easier for them to grow. For agencies structured as pass-through entities, such deductions are critical, allowing for potential reinvestment into business operations, expansion, or hiring.

4. Stimulating Innovation and Investment in Insurtech

Lower interest rates could fuel growth within the insurtech industry, which has faced a decline in investor interest in recent years. Flowers notes that from 2017 to 2020, the insurtech space saw more innovation and funding, and a similar environment under Trump could revitalize the sector.

Increased investor confidence could lead to new products, enhanced underwriting technologies, and customer-focused innovations, which might streamline the insurance experience for policyholders. Lower borrowing costs, coupled with a pro-business climate, could attract more funding to early-stage insurtech companies, accelerating advancements in digital insurance solutions and artificial intelligence-based underwriting processes.

Looking Ahead: Opportunities and Challenges for the Insurance Sector

Trump’s second term is likely to bring a combination of opportunities and challenges for the insurance industry. Lower inflation and tax cuts could stimulate demand and reduce operational costs, while regulatory relief might lighten the load for independent agencies. However, the potential for increased protectionism and material costs may counterbalance some of these gains, especially for insurers with international portfolios.

As the industry prepares for these shifts, insurers may need to focus on adaptability—leveraging the benefits of a favorable tax and regulatory environment while staying vigilant against potential global market constraints.

For more information on navigating your claims when suffering a property loss related to water, fire, or mold, please contact PuroClean of Downers Grove, we can help you understand your options and provide you with the support to restore your property during the casualty.

Call us at (630) 796-0206