PuroClean of Lafayette 
Table of Contents
Can I Use My Own Contractor on an Insurance Claim?
When a burst pipe floods your kitchen or a fire damages your Lafayette home, the last thing you want is confusion about your insurance coverage. One common question homeowners ask is: Can I use my own contractor on an insurance claim?
The short answer is yes — you absolutely can. Homeowners in Indiana and across the U.S. have the right to select their own licensed contractor for repairs after a covered loss. However, the process can be complex if you don’t understand how insurance companies handle claims and contractor relationships.
This article explains your rights, the pros and cons of using your own contractor versus an insurer-recommended one, and how to choose a reputable company in the Lafayette, IN area to ensure your restoration is done right.
Understanding How Insurance Claims Work
When you file a property damage insurance claim — whether for water damage, fire damage, or storm cleanup — your insurer typically sends an adjuster to assess the loss and estimate the repair cost.
To speed things up, some insurance companies maintain networks of “preferred” or “approved” contractors. These vendors have pre-negotiated rates and work directly with the insurer’s billing system. While this arrangement can be convenient, it’s important to know that you are not required to use their contractor.
According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), homeowners have the right to hire any properly licensed contractor they choose, as long as the contractor meets state and local requirements.
Your Right to Choose: What the Law Says
In Indiana, homeowners retain full authority to select their own contractor after an insurance loss. The insurance company’s responsibility is to pay for covered repairs up to the policy limits, not to dictate who performs them.
That means if you prefer a local, certified, and trusted restoration company such as PuroClean of Lafayette, your insurer must honor that decision — provided the repair estimate is fair and reasonable.
Preferred Contractors vs. Independent Contractors
The table below summarizes the main differences between using your insurer’s contractor and choosing your own.
| Option | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance-Preferred Contractor | – Pre-approved by your insurer – Simplifies billing – May start work faster | – May prioritize insurer cost savings – Limited transparency on materials or scope – You have less say in the process |
| Your Own Contractor | – You select who works in your home – Often more transparent communication – Personalized service and accountability | – May require more paperwork – You must ensure estimates align with the insurer’s coverage |
If you value control, transparency, and trust, working with your own contractor — especially one with insurance claim expertise — is often the better long-term choice.
Why Many Homeowners in Lafayette Choose Their Own Contractor
Homeowners in Lafayette, West Lafayette, Dayton, and Battle Ground often prefer working with local companies like PuroClean of Lafayette for several reasons:
- Local Knowledge: Local contractors understand Tippecanoe County building codes, weather conditions, and common causes of water and storm damage.
- Personal Accountability: When you choose a local contractor, you deal directly with a team that values reputation and community trust.
- Faster Communication: Insurance claims involve documentation, inspections, and estimates. A contractor who’s local can respond more quickly to adjuster requests and homeowner questions.
- Quality Workmanship: Many national “preferred vendor” programs prioritize cost efficiency. Independent local contractors often deliver higher-quality repairs using better materials.
How to Choose a Contractor for an Insurance Claim
Choosing a contractor after a disaster isn’t just about getting your property restored — it’s about ensuring the job is done safely, correctly, and covered properly by insurance.
Follow these best practices:
1. Verify Licensing and Certification
In Indiana, contractors must hold proper state and local licenses. For restoration work, look for IICRC-certified professionals — this certification ensures they meet industry standards for water, fire, and mold restoration.
2. Ask About Insurance and Bonding
Reputable contractors carry general liability insurance and workers’ compensation coverage. Ask for proof before signing any agreement.
3. Request Written Estimates
Always get a detailed written estimate outlining the work to be performed, materials to be used, and projected costs. This helps your insurance adjuster compare the quote accurately with the insurer’s estimate.
4. Review References and Reviews
Check Google Reviews, the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and local referrals. A trustworthy Lafayette-area company will have positive feedback and experience with similar restoration projects.
5. Ensure Insurance Claim Experience
Not all contractors understand the nuances of insurance claims. PuroClean of Lafayette, for example, works directly with insurers, documents damage thoroughly, and helps homeowners navigate every step — from estimate approval to final inspection.
How the Process Works When You Choose Your Own Contractor
If you decide to use your own contractor on an insurance claim, here’s a simplified overview of the process:
- Report the Loss: Contact your insurance company immediately after the damage occurs.
- Get an Inspection: Your adjuster inspects the property and prepares an estimate.
- Hire a Contractor: Select a qualified contractor and share the insurer’s estimate.
- Negotiate if Needed: If estimates differ, your contractor can provide additional photos or documentation to justify costs.
- Approve and Begin Work: Once the insurer approves, restoration begins.
- Final Inspection and Payment: After completion, your insurer releases final payment, minus any deductible.
A contractor experienced in insurance restoration will handle much of this communication for you — saving time and stress.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Accepting the insurer’s contractor without research. Compare reviews, pricing, and certifications before deciding.
- Failing to get written documentation. Always document work agreements, timelines, and change orders.
- Ignoring permit requirements. Even emergency repairs may require permits under Lafayette city code.
- Not confirming coverage details. Understand what’s covered and what isn’t before signing off on the work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use my own contractor on an insurance claim in Indiana?
Yes. Indiana homeowners are fully entitled to choose their own licensed contractor for insurance-covered repairs.
Will my insurer pay if I don’t use their contractor?
Yes — as long as the repair estimate is reasonable and aligns with your policy limits. Your insurer covers the cost either way.
Can choosing my own contractor delay the claim?
Usually not. In fact, an experienced insurance-savvy contractor can help you submit paperwork more efficiently.
How can I make sure my contractor’s estimate is accepted?
Ask the contractor to use Xactimate (a common estimating software used by insurers) and provide detailed documentation.
Does PuroClean of Lafayette work with my insurance company?
Yes, we work with all major insurers and help homeowners manage the claims process from start to finish.
Choose PuroClean of Lafayette for Trusted Insurance Claim Restoration
At PuroClean of Lafayette, we specialize in insurance claim restoration — helping homeowners recover quickly and completely after water, fire, mold, or storm damage.
Whether you’re dealing with a burst pipe, smoke damage, or storm-related flooding in Lafayette or nearby areas like Dayton, West Lafayette, or Battle Ground, choose a trusted, local expert who prioritizes your recovery — not your insurer’s bottom line.
Call PuroClean of Lafayette today at (765) 701-4242 for 24/7 emergency restoration services.
Our certified professionals are ready to restore your property and guide you through every step of the insurance claim process.
Summary
- You have the legal right to choose your own contractor on an insurance claim.
- Insurance-preferred contractors aren’t mandatory — they’re only suggestions.
- Always verify licenses, certifications, and references.
- A contractor experienced with insurance claims ensures smoother communication.
- PuroClean of Lafayette serves Lafayette, West Lafayette, Dayton, and nearby areas with certified, insurance-approved restoration services.
PuroClean of Lafayette 